Right to Repair Legislation: State Senate Bills Expanding Consumer Access to Device Repair

For most of consumer electronics history, buying a device meant accepting a practical reality: if it broke, you either took it to the manufacturer's service network, paid for an authorized repair, or replaced it. Independent repair shops were locked out of the tools and parts they needed. Consumers who tried to fix their own devices found that manufacturers withheld diagnostic software, refused to sell replacement parts to non-authorized parties, and designed products to resist repair through software locks and proprietary fasteners.

That structure is now under sustained legislative challenge. Across the United States, state legislatures have been passing right-to-repair laws that require manufacturers to make repair documentation, diagnostic tools, and replacement parts available to independent repair shops and, in some cases, to individual consumers. These laws represent a fundamental shift in the balance of power between manufacturers and the people who own their products, and they have implications for consumers, independent repair businesses, and the broader market for durable goods.

What Right to Repair Means

Right-to-repair legislation, in its basic form, requires manufacturers to provide the resources necessary for products to be repaired by parties other than the manufacturer or its authorized service network. Those resources typically include: diagnostic software and hardware tools needed to identify faults; replacement parts sold at fair and reasonable prices; repair manuals and technical documentation; and access to firmware updates necessary to complete repairs.

The principle behind right-to-repair is property ownership: a consumer who purchases a device should be able to maintain and repair it as they choose. Manufacturers counter that some restrictions are justified by legitimate concerns — product safety, cybersecurity, and protection of proprietary intellectual property. The legislative debate turns on where the line falls between legitimate restriction and anticompetitive gatekeeping of the repair market.

Why Manufacturers Oppose Repair Access

Manufacturer opposition to right-to-repair legislation has been organized and persistent. Their arguments fall into several categories. Security concerns: diagnostic tools that provide deep access to device systems could be exploited to compromise security protections. Safety concerns: improper repairs to products like medical devices, electric vehicles, or high-voltage electronics could injure consumers. Intellectual property concerns: technical documentation and diagnostic software represent proprietary investment that manufacturers argue should not be mandatorily disclosed.

Consumer advocates and independent repair advocates argue that these concerns, while legitimate in some contexts, have been applied far beyond where they are genuinely warranted. A safety argument may be reasonable for a Class III medical device; it is considerably weaker for a smartphone screen replacement or a laptop battery swap. The effect of broad manufacturer repair restrictions has been to channel nearly all repair revenue to manufacturer-controlled service networks — an outcome that is economically advantageous to manufacturers regardless of whether safety or security concerns justify it in any particular case.

Colorado: Agricultural Equipment Right to Repair

Colorado passed SB 22-152, the Agricultural Equipment Right to Repair Act, in 2022, making it the first state in the United States to enact a right-to-repair law applicable to agricultural equipment. The law requires manufacturers of agricultural equipment to make available to independent repair shops and to farmers the same diagnostic tools, repair manuals, and parts that are provided to authorized dealers. It prohibits manufacturers from using technological protection measures to prevent independent repair and from imposing dealer agreements that restrict independent repair access.

The agricultural equipment context is particularly significant. Modern farm equipment is heavily computerized, and manufacturers had used software locks to prevent farmers from repairing their own machinery — creating a situation where a farmer with a broken tractor during harvest could not get service for days because only authorized technicians with proprietary diagnostic tools could perform the repair. The Colorado law directly addressed this operational reality for farming communities.

Minnesota: Digital Electronics Right to Repair

Minnesota enacted HF 1014, the Digital Fair Repair Act, in 2023, covering consumer electronic devices including smartphones, computers, tablets, and home appliances. The Minnesota law requires manufacturers that sell covered electronic equipment in the state to provide owners and independent repair providers with access to the same diagnostic and repair information, parts, and tools available to authorized repair providers. The law was signed by Governor Walz in May 2023.

Minnesota's law is notable for its scope. Rather than restricting coverage to a single product category, it applies broadly to digital electronic products, making it one of the most comprehensive right-to-repair laws in the country at the time of passage. The law includes provisions allowing manufacturers to implement security measures provided those measures do not unreasonably restrict the right to repair.

California's Right to Repair Act

California enacted AB 1183, the Right to Repair Act, signed into law in October 2023. The California law requires manufacturers of electronics and appliances — a product category defined broadly enough to cover the majority of consumer electronic devices — to make available to independent repair providers and consumers the parts, tools, and documentation needed to perform repair. The law applies to products sold in California and sets a minimum repair availability period tied to the product's expected service life.

California's law includes provisions specifically addressing software locks: manufacturers cannot use technological protection measures to prevent or unreasonably restrict repair when the repair does not compromise cybersecurity. The law also requires that replacement parts not be restricted to manufacturer-authorized channels when the restriction serves no legitimate safety or security function.

DMCA Section 1201 and Copyright Exemptions

One of the legal barriers that has historically impeded the right to repair is Section 1201 of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, which prohibits circumvention of technological protection measures — software locks — that protect copyrighted works. Manufacturers have used this provision to argue that bypassing software locks on devices, even to perform repairs, violates federal copyright law regardless of what state repair laws say.

The Copyright Office addresses this tension through a triennial rulemaking process that can grant exemptions to Section 1201 for specific purposes. In recent rulemaking cycles, the Copyright Office has granted exemptions allowing circumvention of software locks on certain product categories — including smartphones, vehicles, and agricultural equipment — for the purpose of diagnosis, maintenance, and repair. These exemptions do not require Congressional action and have incrementally expanded the scope of permissible repair activity under federal copyright law.

State right-to-repair laws operate alongside these exemptions, and together they have progressively reduced the legal barriers to independent repair. Whether a particular repair activity is lawful depends on whether it falls within a current Copyright Office exemption and whether state law imposes any additional requirements or protections.

Federal Efforts and the FTC

At the federal level, the Federal Trade Commission has been active in the right-to-repair space. The FTC issued a report in 2021 finding that manufacturer restrictions on repair harmed consumers and small independent repair businesses without sufficient justification in most cases. The FTC also announced increased enforcement attention to warranty practices that void warranties based on use of independent repair — a practice that had been widespread but that the agency concluded violated the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act. As state consumer protection laws have moved faster than federal reform, the FTC's right-to-repair enforcement has been an important complement to the state legislative wave.

Federal right-to-repair legislation has been introduced in Congress, with proposals covering electronics, agricultural equipment, and medical devices. A federal law would create a uniform national standard rather than the current patchwork of state laws. No comprehensive federal right-to-repair bill had advanced to passage as of mid-2025, but the legislative and regulatory momentum at both the state and federal level continued to build.

Implications for Consumers and Independent Repair Businesses

For consumers in states with right-to-repair laws, the practical effects include greater access to independent repair shops that can now legally obtain the parts and tools they need; potentially lower repair costs as manufacturer service monopolies are reduced; and a longer useful life for products that can be repaired rather than replaced. Consumers who prefer to perform their own repairs benefit from the availability of documentation and parts that were previously restricted.

For independent repair businesses, right-to-repair laws represent a significant market opening. Businesses that were previously unable to service certain products due to parts and tool restrictions can expand their service offerings. The longer-term competitive dynamic is still developing as manufacturers adjust their service strategies in response to legal requirements. Alongside legislative reforms in employment technology and consumer finance, right-to-repair is part of a broader pattern of state legislatures reasserting consumer rights in markets where technological and contractual restrictions had substantially limited them.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does my warranty become void if I use an independent repair shop?

No — not under federal law. The Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act prohibits manufacturers from voiding a warranty solely because a consumer used an independent repair shop or non-OEM parts, unless the manufacturer can demonstrate that the independent repair caused the defect being claimed. The FTC has pursued enforcement actions against manufacturers whose warranty terms improperly implied that warranty coverage depended on using authorized service. Warranty voiding provisions based solely on use of independent repair are generally unenforceable.

Are medical devices covered by right-to-repair laws?

Generally, current state right-to-repair laws exclude medical devices subject to FDA regulation, or treat them in a separate regulatory framework. The safety and cybersecurity concerns are more substantial for implanted and life-critical medical devices than for consumer electronics. However, some state laws cover non-implanted medical equipment used in care facilities, and federal discussions about medical device right to repair have been ongoing. The landscape for medical devices is more complex and evolving more slowly than consumer electronics.

Can manufacturers still charge for repair parts and documentation under these laws?

Yes. Right-to-repair laws require manufacturers to make parts and documentation available, not to provide them for free. The laws typically require that pricing be fair and reasonable — meaning the manufacturer cannot effectively circumvent the law by charging prices that make independent repair economically impossible. What constitutes a fair and reasonable price in any specific instance may depend on how the applicable law defines that standard and how it is enforced.

Do right-to-repair laws apply to products purchased before the law took effect?

State laws vary on this. Some laws apply to products sold in the state after the law's effective date; others apply to manufacturers that sell covered products in the state, which may create obligations regarding older products still in use. The general expectation is that newly sold products in covered states must comply with repair availability requirements, while obligations for legacy products depend on the specific statutory language of each state's law.